Humankind Vs Civilization 6: Which Is Better?

The Humankind vs Civilization 6 debate is hotly contested because both titles share similarities in developing a nation and culture, battling for survival, and strategic planning. On the other hand, both titles have various differences in retrospect to each other. 

Comparison Between Humankind And Civ 6

Here’s a quick comparison between Humankind and Civ 6. This comparison table includes some major aspects of the two games like the pacing, combat, and progression:

Similarities

While exploring the different aspects of Humankind vs Civilization 6, we will first discuss their similarities. Both of these games are similar in terms of the following:

• Gameplay Mechanics.
• Cultural Progression.
• Diplomacy and Warfare.
• Victory Conditions.

Gameplay Mechanics

1. Starting with a Single City: Players begin with a single city and expand their civilization over time.
2. Gradual Growth: Expansion involves managing resources, researching technologies, and expanding territory.
3. Turn-Based System: Both games employ a turn-based system for unit movement, decision-making, and battles.
4. Strategic Planning: Success requires careful planning and strategic decisions, focusing on various aspects like science, culture, diplomacy, or military might.
5. Tech Tree: A tech tree unlocks new technologies, units, and buildings as players progress through different historical eras.
6. Diplomacy and Warfare: Interactions with other civilizations, trade, alliances, and military conquests play key roles in both games.

Cultural Progression

Cultural progression in both Humankind and Civilization 6 is marked by different historical eras, like Ancient, Medieval, Renaissance, and Modern. Advancing through these eras unlocks new technologies and units, enabling players to construct advanced structures, expand their influence, and strengthen their civilization.

This progression is a central gameplay element, guiding players from an early era through various historical periods. Effective resource management and strategic choices shape the direction and success of their civilization.

Diplomacy And Warfare

Diplomacy and warfare are essential aspects of both games:

Diplomacy:

• Players interact with other civilizations, forming alliances, negotiating trades, and engaging in diplomatic relations.
• Peaceful options include alliances, trade, and technology exchange.
• Aggressive diplomacy, like espionage and sabotage, can provide advantages.

Warfare:

• Warfare is turn-based and involves using military units.
• Players manage resources and strategically position units for battle.
• Unit types (ranged, melee) add complexity, requiring tactical decisions in combat.

These elements emphasize the importance of diplomacy and military strategy in achieving success and expansion in both games.

Victory Conditions

Both Civilization 6 and Humankind offer multiple victory conditions, though they differ in some aspects:

Civilization 6 Victory Conditions:

1. Scientific Victory: Requires researching and launching a spacecraft to Alpha Centauri.
2. Cultural Victory: Achieved by having the most influential culture globally.
3. Military Victory: Conquer all other civilizations on the map.
4. Diplomatic Victory: Gain the support of the majority of city-states and civilizations.

Humankind Victory Conditions:

1. Military Conquest: Achieved through military dominance.
2. Cultural Dominance: Becoming the most culturally influential civilization.
3. Scientific Achievement: Requires researching all technologies in the tech tree.
4. Economic Dominance: Achieved through economic superiority.
5. Diplomatic Influence: Gained by diplomatic actions and alliances.

Differences

Now comes differences, the center of discussion of our hot topic, Humankind vs Civilization 6. Both of the games are dis-similar in terms of:

• Unit Stacking.
• Combat.
• City Management.
• Progression through different eras of history.

Unit Stacking

Civilization 6 (Civ 6):

• Allows stacking multiple units on the same tile.
• Complex tactical options, combining different unit types.
• Can lead to overcrowded battlefields.

Humankind:

• Units cannot stack, simplifying combat.
• Requires strategic unit positioning and use of abilities.
• Encourages tactical thinking and strategic gameplay.

While Civ 6’s unit stacking offers complex tactics, Humankind’s non-stacking system promotes strategic positioning and thoughtful use of unit abilities, catering to players who prefer a different level of complexity in their gameplay experience.

Combat

Both Humankind and Civilization 6 incorporate combat as a fundamental element, but they have distinct approaches:

Humankind Combat:

• Emphasizes strategic unit positioning.
• Units possess unique abilities that can be strategically used in battle.
• Requires thoughtful planning and strategy for success.

  

Civilization 6 Combat:

• Terrain plays a crucial role in combat.
• Terrain features like high ground or natural barriers can be used tactically.
• Encourages players to utilize the environment for advantageous combat positioning.

City Management

City management differs between Humankind and Civilization 6:

Civilization 6 City Management:

• Focuses on individual city management.
• Involves building infrastructure, assigning workers, and constructing buildings.
• Each city has its set of resources and requires individual management.

Humankind City Management:

• Employs a more macro-focused approach.
• Cities represented as districts, placed for strategic resource optimization.
• Emphasizes empire-wide considerations and district interactions.

The distinct city management styles offer players varied gameplay experiences, with Civilization 6 focusing on individual city development and Humankind taking a broader empire-level perspective.

Progression Through Different Eras Of History

Civilization 6 Era Progression:

• Progression via researching technologies and building Wonders.
• Each era unlocks new technologies, units, and buildings, following a linear historical path.
• Emphasizes historical accuracy.

Humankind Era Progression:

• Progression through combining different cultures to create a unique civilization.
• Offers customization and tailoring to player’s playstyle and strategy.
• Faster pace, allowing quicker progression through different eras compared to Civilization 6.

These differences in era progression contribute to distinct gameplay experiences, with Civilization 6 offering a historically accurate, linear path and Humankind providing more flexibility and customization.

Which Game Is Better?

It’s difficult to say which game is objectively better, as both Humankind and Civilization 6 offer unique and engaging gameplay experiences. Ultimately, the choice between the two games comes down to personal preference.

• Players who enjoy a more customizable and faster-paced experience may prefer Humankind, which offers a unique approach to cultural progression and a streamlined gameplay experience.
• On the other hand, players who enjoy a more historical and slower-paced approach to gameplay may prefer Civilization 6, which emphasizes historical accuracy and a linear path of progression.

You would now be fully aware of the similarities and differences between both games. However, the choice is all yours. If you are still confused, you can refer to the subreddit to know what exactly the players are up to.

If you are the kind of a person that prefers fast pace games, then you would probably want to go with Humankind. But if you prefer going slow and enjoying every bit of a game, Civ 6 would do it for you. Both games are highly enriched with tactics and strategies, so the overall gameplay is similar.

You will get an immense experience of dealing with cultures and cultural progression in Humankind. If you are fond of historical gameplay, Civ 6 deals more with historical and linear progression.

Next

• BEST Natural Wonders In Civ 6
• Civ 6 War Weariness
• Civilization 6: All Secret Societies
• BEST Pantheons In Civ 6