Madden NFL 24 Review – A Terrible New Entry

On-field innovations clash with off-field staleness.

Madden NFL 24 Review
  • Story And Setting
  • Gameplay
  • Visuals And Performance


Madden NFL 24 might appeal to longtime fans, but it’s important to note that it fails to reach the end zone due to some critical fumbles.

  • Developer: EA Tiburon
  • Publisher: EA Sports
  • Release Date: August 18, 2023
  • Platforms: PC, Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One, PlayStation 5, PlayStation 4
  • Tested On: PC


  • Stunning Visuals
  • Fluid Gameplay


  • Lackuster Superstar Mode
  • Menu Performance Issues
  • Shallow Minigames
  • Not Enough Innovation

Since the latter part of the last decade, each new entry in the sports games genre has garnered a negative, and well deserved, reputation for recycling mechanics, splashing a new coat of paint, and releasing at full prices accompanied by predatory microtransactions.

As the hype builds for a new NFL season, so does the anticipation for EA Tiburon’s offering, promising an evolution from its predecessor. However, as the ball is snapped and the game unfolds, it’s clear that while there are some promising aspects, there are also some fumbles that keep this edition from reaching its full potential.

So let’s lace up our virtual shoes and navigate the muddy waters of Madden NFL 24, exploring both its standout moments and its stumbling blocks.

Story And Setting

Madden NFL 24 Story and Setting
Story And Setting. (Image by eXputer)

Story mode has never been the primary focus of sports games, as modes like Ultimate Team have always been the dominating money-printing machine. But developers still try to tack on some half-baked story elements to somehow justify the egregious price tag.

In the latest installment of the iconic football franchise, the story elements take center stage in certain modes, offering players a mix of engaging narratives and familiar environments.

One of the standout features in Madden NFL 24 is the return of Superstar Mode, a staple of the franchise that allows players to create their own football player and guide them through their journey from rookie to NFL star.

The story begins with the NFL Combine, where players must showcase their skills to impress scouts and secure their place in the draft. This addition injects a sense of drama and authenticity into the game, as players navigate the pressures of the Combine while aiming to leave a lasting impression on team representatives.

The lack of major improvements in presentation, despite the technological leaps in other areas, leaves a noticeable gap in the overall immersion.

However, the Superstar Mode’s narrative falls somewhat short in terms of originality and depth. The storylines feel generic and fail to offer players any level of emotional engagement. While the inclusion of the NFL knowledge quiz during press interviews is a nice touch for football enthusiasts, it might leave casual players feeling disconnected from the experience.

The mode’s social feed, featuring live Madden cast videos, adds a dynamic aspect but struggles to deliver captivating content consistently. The choice-based day-to-day schedule management aspect of the mode could have offered more variety and impact on gameplay, rather than feeling like a mundane chore.

As players progress through Superstar Mode, they encounter mini-games that provide a break from traditional gameplay. There are 26 minigames in total, including Rushing Attack where you can hone your rushing skills by passing through defenders, and Passing Skeleton in which you can practice your passes with a limited number of receivers.

Although they are fun the first few times and are a great way to earn experience points, their limited variety, especially when tied to specific player positions, leads to a feeling of repetitiveness gradually. A  considerable number of these mini-games are essentially variations, often involving adding extra defenders or altering your starting position on the field.

On the field, this title manages to capture the essence of NFL stadiums and the overall atmosphere of a football game. However, it still falls short of fully replicating the presentation of real-life NFL broadcasts. While the commentary featuring Charles Davis and Brandon Gaudin is solid, occasional inaccuracies and repetitive lines remind players that they’re in a virtual world.

The lack of major improvements in presentation, despite the technological leaps in other areas, leaves a noticeable gap in the overall immersion.


Madden NFL 24 Gameplay
Gameplay. (Image Captured by eXputer)

Madden NFL 24 delivers an impressive gameplay experience that not only refines existing mechanics but also introduces innovative features to elevate the gridiron action.

One of the most noteworthy improvements is the enhanced player movement and animation. Powered by the SAPIEN skeletal system, the game offers a significant leap in the realism of player motions. Gone are the days of awkward, unnatural movements on the field. Instead, players now move with a level of fluidity and authenticity that mirrors real NFL athletes.

This overhaul is evident in every aspect, from the way players tackle opponents to the smoothness of ball catches. The result is a gameplay experience that feels more immersive and visually striking than ever before.

The game’s on-field action has received subtle yet impactful tweaks, refining existing mechanics to create a more engaging and satisfying football simulation. Pass catchers now catch the ball in stride with better precision, leading to more dynamic plays and long touchdowns.

Powered by the SAPIEN skeletal system, the game offers a significant leap in the realism of player motions.

This subtle adjustment adds a layer of excitement and strategic depth to passing plays, making the passing game feel more dynamic and rewarding. Additionally, the Hit Stick tackle mechanic has been recalibrated to reduce its reliability, resulting in a more balanced defensive approach where players can’t solely rely on forcing fumbles through tackles.

The running game has seen notable improvements as well. The Tactical Blocking System, a new addition, revolutionizes how AI linemen and blockers engage with defenders. This change makes running the ball a more strategic endeavor, as players can identify and exploit gaps in the defensive line to create explosive plays.

The result is a more lifelike ground game that rewards players’ awareness and decision-making, enhancing the overall football strategy experience.

While the gameplay improvements are evident and commendable, Madden NFL 24 isn’t without its hiccups. The menus and navigation can feel sluggish, with occasional stutters and crashes detracting from the overall experience.

Additionally, certain animations, particularly interactions between players and sideline elements, can still come across as awkward and jarring, momentarily breaking the immersion. The SAPIEN system significantly improves animation, but some rough edges still persist.

Despite these minor shortcomings, the overall gameplay sets a new standard for football simulations. The focus on refining core mechanics, introducing innovative features, and enhancing player movement creates a dynamic and immersive experience that captures the essence of the NFL.

Also, the improvements in passing, running, and tackling mechanics provide a satisfying blend of realism and strategy, rewarding players for their skill and decision-making on the field.

Visuals And Performance

Madden NFL 24 Visuals
Visuals. (Image by eXputer)

Visually, Madden NFL 24 is a feast for the eyes. The game’s upgraded graphics engine showcases a level of detail and realism that takes the virtual football experience to new heights. Players’ movements are more fluid, and the way they interact with the environment and each other feels remarkably natural.

This newfound realism extends to the stadiums, weather effects, and lighting, creating an atmosphere that closely mirrors the excitement of an actual NFL game.

The fluidity of player movements and the responsiveness of controls contribute to a more engaging and enjoyable gameplay experience.

The attention to detail extends beyond the players themselves. Stadiums are rendered with remarkable accuracy, capturing the unique characteristics of each venue. From the vibrant colors of the field to the energetic crowds, the game effectively replicates the electrifying atmosphere of game day.

Weather effects, including rain and snow, add an extra layer of immersion, affecting gameplay dynamics and visual aesthetics. The result is a game that’s visually captivating and brings the spectacle of the NFL to life in your living room.

In terms of next-gen performance, Madden NFL 24 takes advantage of the capabilities of modern hardware. On the Xbox Series X and PlayStation 5, the game boasts faster loading times, improved frame rates, and enhanced graphical fidelity.

The fluidity of player movements and the responsiveness of controls contribute to a more engaging and enjoyable gameplay experience. These improvements highlight the potential of the new hardware and elevate the overall quality of the game.

However, despite taking advantage of next-gen hardware, there are a number of noticeable performance inconsistencies. There are instances of menu lag, stutters, and occasional crashes that disrupt the overall experience.

These issues are particularly noticeable during navigation through menus, which can be frustrating and detract from the game’s fluidity. Although these problems are not game-breaking, they do interrupt the otherwise polished presentation that the game aims to achieve.


Verdict. (Captured by eXputer)

Madden NFL 24 captures the essence of American football on the virtual field with improved animations and gameplay mechanics. Yet, it’s clear that Madden is in dire need of a comprehensive overhaul from the ground up.

The series’ annual release cycle and the overwhelming prominence of the revenue-generating Ultimate Team Mode seem to result in mere surface-level changes that fail to address deeper issues. Fans will undoubtedly enjoy the refined gameplay and enhanced visuals, but the experience falls short of its potential due to these persistent drawbacks.

As the NFL season kicks off, Madden NFL 24 might serve as a suitable companion, but it’s important to acknowledge that it struggles to reach the end zone of excellence due to some critical fumbles.

This has been our Madden NFL 24 Review. While you’re here, consider checking out some of our other articles. 

Was this article helpful?

Thanks! Do share your feedback with us. ⚡

How could we improve this post? Please Help us. ✍

Asad Ahmed

Asad Ahmad is a Games Reviewer on eXputer who’s combined his passion for writing and gaming into a sweet blend of content for his audience to enjoy. He started off his gaming journey in the RTS genre but settled on RPGs like Skyrim as his go-to games. He’s an Electrical Engineering major with a substantial amount of writing experience in reviewing and writing for games. Experience: 2+ Years || Education: Bachelors in Electrical Engineering || Published 50+ Game Reviews

Related Articles